Two Melee Crit Builds (Vote, and Improve) Elemental Boost vs Bleeding Edge

I have been experimenting with a couple of universal critical hit builds. Since resources are limited unless significant effort is invested, I aimed to concentrate on one or two builds. I concluded that a critical hit build was the superior option. Although elemental critical is the strongest, I see potential in Bleeding Edge, but I sense it lacks something. Which do you think is better and what would you change.

Armor minimal level 8

Elemental Crit: This is my main build, I just need 1 more Crit Boost smelt.

H-Silver Rath
C-Carnival
G-Azure Rath
B-Pink Rath
L-Silver Rath
Driftsmelt: Crit Eye 1, Weak Ex 1, Crit Boost 3

Bleeding Edge: I need all smelts, and legging needs 1 more upgrade.

H-Ebony O
C-Rath
G-Ebony O
B-Gold Rath
L-Mizutsune
Driftsmelt: Crit Boost 5